Aliens That Take Over Our Bodies: The Thing vs Body Snatchers

Aliens That Take Over Our Bodies: <a target="_blank" href="https://www.google.com/search?ved=1t:260882&q=The+Thing&bbid=8281819812793584616&bpid=2993791199389569903" data-preview>The Thing</a> vs Body Snatchers

Aliens That Take Over Our Bodies: The Thing vs Body Snatchers


Hollywood's aliens usually have a face: two eyes, a mouth and, in the cheaper productions, a zip at the back. We read them as we read anyone, and that is the comfort. The films here take the face away, leaving a seed pod, a parasite, or a thing that wears whoever it met last.

Short answer: In Invasion of the Body Snatchers, plant-like pods replace sleeping people with emotionless duplicates, so the horror is conformity: slow, quiet and polite. In The Thing, one organism absorbs and imitates whatever it meets, so the horror is isolation and distrust, tested in the 1982 film with a blood sample.


Key takeaways

  • Body Snatchers has no film sequel that I can find, only three remakes of the 1956 film (1978, 1993 and 2007), all from Jack Finney's novel (a Collier's serial in 1954, a book in 1955).
  • The Thing (1982) is, per Wikipedia, a second adaptation of Campbell's 1938 novella Who Goes There?, though critics often call it a remake of the 1951 film. The 2011 film is a direct prequel to it.
  • The 1951 film turned the shapeshifter into a blood-drinking humanoid with a vegetable structure.
  • The Hidden (1987) and The Puppet Masters (novel 1951, film 1994) also put alien parasites inside people on Earth.
  • The Alien films, set among the stars, are left out.

Next come why a faceless alien frightens us more, the two novels, each franchise in order, the sequel count, paranoia and endings, then the wider run of alien parasite movies and other movies where aliens take over bodies on Earth. Where sources disagree, I say so.

The Alien With No Face

Category: critical opinion, backed by documented film history

Why are the best movie aliens the ones with no face? Because a face lets us read intentions, and these films take that away, so the fear moves to the people standing next to us. That is my critical view, not a measured fact, and plenty of good aliens do have faces.

The Humanoid Default

Wikipedia describes the "little green men" as small humanoids with green skin and sometimes antennae, a phrase that spread with the flying-saucer reports of the 1950s. The grey alien, hairless with a large head and large eyes, became popular after the Barney and Betty Hill abduction claim of 1961. Wikipedia also records, citing a 2023 BBC article, that once actors played screen aliens, humanlike ones with a few odd features became the standard for budget reasons. Even Ridley Scott's Prometheus (2012) gives us the Engineers, tall humanoids whose DNA, in the story, matches ours. The pattern is my observation, not a count, and not universal: Wikipedia notes that H. G. Wells's Martians (1898) were non-humanoid.

The Alien You Cannot See

Campbell's Who Goes There? (Astounding Science Fiction, August 1938, under the name Don A. Stuart) offered a shapeless alternative: Antarctic researchers find a creature able to absorb and perfectly imitate any living being. The 1951 film, with Christian Nyby credited as director and Howard Hawks's role disputed, did not keep the idea. Per Wikipedia, its screenplay made the creature, played by James Arness, a humanoid with a vegetable cellular structure that feeds on blood. The shapeshifter returned in Carpenter's The Thing (1982), where Rob Bottin's team built a creature that could take any form, with $1.5 million of a $15 million budget. Bill Lancaster's script, Wikipedia says, kept it largely concealed, and Bottin persuaded Carpenter to show more.

The Neighbour Who Is Not Your Neighbour

Finney's The Body Snatchers gives a third answer. Seeds from space grow into plantlike pods that replace sleeping people with perfect duplicates, with the same memories and scars but no human emotion. Don Siegel's 1956 film keeps the trait, and the slang "pod people" comes from those emotionless copies. Nobody in this story meets an alien. They meet a spouse who is slightly wrong.

Why No Face Is Scarier

My argument is a critic's, not a finding: a face lets us read intent, and these films deny us that. A pod person wears the face you already trust, and any face in The Thing might be borrowed. The fear moves from the monster to the people around us, so both stories turn on whom to trust. Not everyone was convinced. Wikipedia's summary of 1982 reviews says some critics saw the creature's lack of a single shape as a weakness, and one found the 1951 version easier to follow.

Two Franchises and a Wider Family

Two more titles share the trait. In The Hidden, a slug-like alien moves from one human host to the next, and The Puppet Masters brings mind-controlling parasites. I looked at The Hidden and The Thing through fear in an earlier post; here the subject is the creatures and the film histories. For the genre's longer run, see my Halloween horror guide. Next come the two novels.

Two Novels: Who Goes There? and The Body Snatchers

Category: documented literary history, with a little critical opinion

Which novels are The Thing and Body Snatchers based on? Campbell's Who Goes There? novella is the source of the 1951 and 1982 films, and the 2011 film is a prequel to the second. Jack Finney's The Body Snatchers is the source of all four Body Snatchers films. Both are about not knowing who is who.

The Who Goes There? Novella

Wikipedia says Argosy turned the story down and F. Orlin Tremaine, Campbell's predecessor at Astounding, accepted it after trimming. Campbell was editor by the time it ran. The magazine version has 12 chapters, and a 14-chapter text appears in later collections. The base has 37 men, and the story already contains a blood test: heated wire, a vial of blood, and a recoil that gives a man away. In 1973 the Science Fiction Writers of America voted it among the most influential and memorable science fiction ever written, and it appeared in The Science Fiction Hall of Fame, Volume Two. Campbell's later editorials are a separate matter. Wikipedia records 1960s essays defending segregation, and the new-writer award that bore his name was renamed in 2019.

Frozen Hell, the Longer Original

In 2018 the biographer Alec Nevala-Lee found drafts of a longer version among Campbell's papers sent to Harvard. Wikipedia says the magazine story was a shortened form of it. Wildside Press published an edited text as Frozen Hell in 2019, with e-books in January for Kickstarter backers and print copies in June. Universal and Blumhouse announced a new film drawing on it in 2020, and I have found no release.

What the Films Changed

Bill Lancaster's script, Wikipedia says, cut the cast from 37 to 12 and opened mid-action instead of in flashback. The 1982 film also omits the creature's telepathy. On the blood test, Wikipedia disagrees with itself: its film page credits Lancaster with the idea, while its novella page describes one in Campbell's plot. I haven't read the text to settle it.

The Body Snatchers, the Jack Finney Book

Wikipedia places Finney's story in Mill Valley, in Marin County, not the film's Santa Mira. Collier's ran it in three parts, the first on 26 November 1954, per ISFDB. The duplicates live about five years and cannot reproduce, so left alone they would use the planet up and move on. Damon Knight objected in 1967 that light pressure could not carry three-foot pods across space. Anthony Boucher called the book "intensely readable and unpredictably ingenious," and Groff Conklin found it unoriginal. Beware the 1978 text: ISFDB lists it as a rewrite, and reviewers say it moves the story to 1976. This section describes the original.

Endings, Allegory and Heinlein

In the novel, the aliens leave of their own accord, having judged humans too stubborn to subdue, and the duplicates left behind die. Wikipedia calls this optimistic and says the first three films went darker. It gives no reason, so my guess is that a screaming man on a highway dramatises better than a departing swarm. Wikipedia relays an interviewer's report that Finney claimed no specific political allegory, though John Clute noted that others read the spore-people as a loss of freedom. Wikipedia also says the novel is often compared with Heinlein's The Puppet Masters (1951), three years earlier. I found no source claiming one borrowed from the other.

Two Novels: Who Goes There? and The Body Snatchers

Category: documented literary history, with a little critical opinion

Which novels are The Thing and Body Snatchers based on? Campbell's Who Goes There? novella is the source of the 1951 and 1982 films, and the 2011 film is a prequel to the second. Jack Finney's The Body Snatchers is the source of all four Body Snatchers films. Both are about not knowing who is who.

The Who Goes There? Novella

Wikipedia says Argosy turned the story down and F. Orlin Tremaine, Campbell's predecessor at Astounding, accepted it after trimming. Campbell was editor by the time it ran. The magazine version has 12 chapters, and a 14-chapter text appears in later collections. The base has 37 men, and the story already contains a blood test: heated wire, a vial of blood, and a recoil that gives a man away. In 1973 the Science Fiction Writers of America voted it among the most influential and memorable science fiction ever written, and it appeared in The Science Fiction Hall of Fame, Volume Two. Campbell's later editorials are a separate matter. Wikipedia records 1960s essays defending segregation, and the new-writer award that bore his name was renamed in 2019.

Frozen Hell, the Longer Original

In 2018 the biographer Alec Nevala-Lee found drafts of a longer version among Campbell's papers sent to Harvard. Wikipedia says the magazine story was a shortened form of it. Wildside Press published an edited text as Frozen Hell in 2019, with e-books in January for Kickstarter backers and print copies in June. Universal and Blumhouse announced a new film drawing on it in 2020, and I have found no release.

What the Films Changed

Bill Lancaster's script, Wikipedia says, cut the cast from 37 to 12 and opened mid-action instead of in flashback. The 1982 film also omits the creature's telepathy. On the blood test, Wikipedia disagrees with itself: its film page credits Lancaster with the idea, while its novella page describes one in Campbell's plot. I haven't read the text to settle it.

The Body Snatchers, the Jack Finney Book

Wikipedia places Finney's story in Mill Valley, in Marin County, not the film's Santa Mira. Collier's ran it in three parts, the first on 26 November 1954, per ISFDB. The duplicates live about five years and cannot reproduce, so left alone they would use the planet up and move on. Damon Knight objected in 1967 that light pressure could not carry three-foot pods across space. Anthony Boucher called the book "intensely readable and unpredictably ingenious," and Groff Conklin found it unoriginal. Beware the 1978 text: ISFDB lists it as a rewrite, and reviewers say it moves the story to 1976. This section describes the original.

Endings, Allegory and Heinlein

In the novel, the aliens leave of their own accord, having judged humans too stubborn to subdue, and the duplicates left behind die. Wikipedia calls this optimistic and says the first three films went darker. It gives no reason, so my guess is that a screaming man on a highway dramatises better than a departing swarm. Wikipedia relays an interviewer's report that Finney claimed no specific political allegory, though John Clute noted that others read the spore-people as a loss of freedom. Wikipedia also says the novel is often compared with Heinlein's The Puppet Masters (1951), three years earlier. I found no source claiming one borrowed from the other.

The Thing in Order: 1951, 1982, 2011

Category: documented film history, with critical opinion

Is The Thing a remake, and is The Thing 2011 a prequel? The 1982 film is a second adaptation of Campbell's novella, though Universal also held remake rights to the 1951 film. The 2011 film is a prequel, not a remake, and ends where the 1982 film begins. By release, the Thing movies in order are 1951, 1982 and 2011. By story, 2011 comes just before 1982.

The Thing from Another World (1951)

RKO released it on 7 April 1951. Charles Lederer takes the screenplay credit, with Hawks and Ben Hecht uncredited, and Hawks bought the rights to Who Goes There? for $1,250. Air Force men, led by Kenneth Tobey, share a polar outpost with scientists. Wikipedia says the overlapping dialogue was meant for realism and was hard to master. The film ends on a warning to "keep watching the skies." It earned $1.95 million in US rentals, 46th for 1951, and holds 87% on Rotten Tomatoes from 68 reviews (11 October 2026).

The Thing 1982: Flop, Then Classic

Carpenter's film opened on 25 June 1982, two weeks after E.T. and on the same day as Blade Runner, which I covered in a post on the film and a Kim Wilde song. Audiences had just met an alien who wanted to phone home, and this one wanted their bodies. Kurt Russell leads, and Ennio Morricone wrote the score. Reviews were negative, and Christian Nyby, the 1951 director, said, "If you want blood, go to the slaughterhouse." It grossed $19.6 million on a $15 million budget, which Wikipedia sums up as neither a failure nor a hit. Home video made it a classic: 85% on Rotten Tomatoes from 93 reviews, and the National Film Registry in 2025. Carpenter counts it the first of his "Apocalypse Trilogy," with Prince of Darkness and In the Mouth of Madness.

The Thing 2011: The Prequel

Matthijs van Heijningen Jr. directed it from an Eric Heisserer script, and it opened on 14 October 2011. This Thing prequel follows the Norwegian team at Thule station in winter 1982, with Mary Elizabeth Winstead as the paleontologist Kate Lloyd. It closes on a Norwegian helicopter chasing a dog, which is where the 1982 film starts. Wikipedia says the producers chose a prequel because a remake would be like painting "a moustache on the Mona Lisa." It cost $38 million, grossed $31.5 million and scores 34% from 172 reviews. The director says the creatures were built practically, then "it looked a bit like an 80s movie," so CG went over them. In my view, that was its worst decision.

Remake, Adaptation or Prequel?

Wikipedia's text calls 1982 an adaptation, yet its categories file it under remakes. In 1976 Wilbur Stark bought the remake rights to 23 RKO films, including the 1951 one, and Universal acquired them from him. Lancaster, though, Wikipedia says, did not want to remake the film, and the producers wanted to stay closer to the novella. Complex still called it the "greatest genre remake of all time." My reading is a remake on the legal side, an adaptation on the creative side, and neither word for 2011.

The Other Things, and What to Watch First

The real sequels are not films. Dark Horse published four comic sequels from December 1991, and a 2002 game set after the film was remastered in 2024. Asked about a sequel at Fan Expo Chicago in August 2026, Carpenter said, "We're working on it now," then, "I don't know. We'll see." Dread Central notes he said nearly the same in 2025. Nothing is official. On what to watch first, release order is my taste, not a rule: 1951, 1982, then 2011. Seeing 2011 first turns the 1982 opening, a helicopter chasing a dog, from a mystery into a recap.

Invasion of the Body Snatchers in Order: 1956, 1978, 1993, 2007

Category: documented film history, with critical opinion

How many Body Snatchers movies are there, and in what order? Four official films, all from Finney's novel: 1956, 1978, 1993 and 2007. None is a sequel. Wikipedia calls the last three adaptations, though most people say Invasion of the Body Snatchers remakes. A fifth, Assimilate (2019), is disputed. Rotten Tomatoes scores were checked on 11 October 2026.

Invasion of the Body Snatchers 1956: The Invented Town

Don Siegel directed it for the producer Walter Wanger from Daniel Mainwaring's screenplay, and Allied Artists released it on 5 February 1956, with Kevin McCarthy and Dana Wynter. Santa Mira is the film's invention. Wanger and Siegel wanted Finney's Mill Valley, found it too expensive, and built the town from Los Angeles locations. Wikipedia gives the budget as $416,911 in one place and $382,190 in another. The studio insisted on a framing prologue and epilogue, with Whit Bissell as a psychiatrist, and Siegel said such additions "nearly ruined" the film. He called the McCarthy-era reading "inescapable" but played it down. The film holds 97% on Rotten Tomatoes from 58 reviews (Wikipedia still says 98%) and joined the National Film Registry in 1994.

Invasion of the Body Snatchers 1978: San Francisco

Philip Kaufman directed from W. D. Richter's script, with Robert H. Solo producing, and United Artists opened it on 22 December 1978. Donald Sutherland, Brooke Adams, Jeff Goldblum, Leonard Nimoy and Veronica Cartwright star, and the story moves to San Francisco. McCarthy turns up as a man warning passing cars, and Siegel plays a taxi driver. Wikipedia gives McCarthy's line two ways, "You're next" and "They're coming!", so I won't pick. Ben Burtt, fresh from Star Wars, designed the pod people's shriek, which Kaufman said included a pig's squeal. Wikipedia's text puts the budget at $350,000, but its infobox, AFI Catalog and TMDB say $3.5 million, which I use. It grossed about $24.9 million in the US and holds 93% from 76 reviews. In my 2018 post on Forsaken and the Sutherlands, I called it the best of the series.

Body Snatchers 1993: The Army Base

Abel Ferrara directed for Warner Bros. and Solo, from a screenplay by Stuart Gordon, Dennis Paoli and Nicholas St. John. It moves to an Army base in Alabama and makes a teenager, Marti (Gabrielle Anwar), the lead, with Meg Tilly and Forest Whitaker. Solo, Wikipedia says, insisted it was not a remake. It played Cannes on 15 May 1993 but reached US theatres on 14 January 1994, in a few dozen, and grossed $428,868 on a $12 million budget. Roger Ebert gave it four stars, while a Washington Post critic called it "a soulless replica." It is the least seen of the four, and it holds 70% from 33 reviews.

The Invasion 2007: A Fungus and a Vaccine

Oliver Hirschbiegel directed it from David Kajganich's script, with Nicole Kidman and Daniel Craig, and Warner Bros. released it on 17 August 2007. There are no pods. A fungus-like organism arrives on a crashed Space Shuttle and takes people during REM sleep, and a vaccine reverses it. Unhappy with the first cut, Warner hired the Wachowskis for extra writing and James McTeigue, uncredited, for reshoots. Wikipedia gives a $65 to $80 million budget and a $40.2 million worldwide gross. It holds 20% from 163 reviews, and Ebert called it "the fourth, and the least."

Assimilate, the Echoes and the Missing Sequels

Assimilate (2019), by John Murlowski and Steven Palmer Peterson, is a teen thriller about bug bites and copies. Wikipedia's novel page lists it as based on Finney, but its own page never names him. CinemaBlend counts it as the fifth film while saying the makers do not credit Finney. I leave it out, though I have not seen the end credits. The Faculty (1998) and Pluribus (Apple TV, 2025) are echoes, not adaptations. No film sequel exists. Gordon said Solo planned some after 1993, including one in Washington, D.C., and none was made. Warner reported a new remake in 2017, with Justin Lin reported in October 2023, and I found no release date.

How Many Sequels? The Honest Count

Category: documented film history, with critical opinion

Is there a The Thing sequel, and are there Invasion of the Body Snatchers sequels? The Thing has no film sequel: the real sequels are a 2002 game and comics, and the 2011 film is a prequel. Body Snatchers has no official sequels and three remakes. As for The Thing 2, it is still only talk.

The Count in One Table

FranchiseTitleYearStatusSource note
The ThingThe Thing from Another World1951Original adaptationCampbell's novella
The ThingThe Thing1982Second adaptation; remake disputedWikipedia's text and categories disagree
The ThingThe Thing2011PrequelNot a sequel; ends where 1982 begins
The ThingThe Thing (video game)2002Sequel (game)A second game was cancelled in 2003
The ThingDark Horse comics1991 to 1993Four comic sequelsWikipedia's count; one is an "alternative sequel" ignoring the rest
The ThingThe Northman Nightmare2011Digital comic, three partsPrequel on one Wikipedia page, unrelated standalone on another; set in Greenland
The ThingReturn of the Thing miniseries2005Unmade sequelFour hours planned; Darabont producing; stalled partly on budget (Syfy Wire)
The ThingKate Lloyd sequelAfter 2011UnmadeDirector's oil-platform idea; dropped after the prequel underperformed (Syfy Wire)
The ThingFrozen Hell project2020Announced; no release foundWikipedia and IGN say remake; Vulture says adaptation of the source
The ThingCarpenter's sequel talkAugust 2026UnconfirmedDread Central, 14 August 2026; no director, cast or date
Body SnatchersInvasion of the Body Snatchers1956Original adaptationFinney wrote no sequel; I found no sequel novel or comic
Body Snatchers1978, 1993 and 2007 films1978 to 2007Remakes or adaptations, no sequelsWikipedia says adaptations; LitReactor (2015) calls 1978 "also a sequel", 1993 "an indirect sequel"
Body SnatchersAssimilate2019Disputed fifth adaptationWikipedia's novel page lists it; CinemaBlend counts it
Body SnatchersSolo's planned sequelsAfter 1993UnmadePer Stuart Gordon (Wikipedia); a 2007 film came instead
Body SnatchersWarner remake2017In development; no dateVariety, 2017; Justin Lin reported in 2023; no later update found
Body SnatchersThe Faculty, Pluribus1998, 2025Echoes, not sequelsWikipedia lists The Faculty as based on Finney; I call both echoes

Why So Few Sequels?

The documented reasons are thin, so I mark my own reading. Return of the Thing stalled partly on budget, its writer says, while Universal chose the 2011 prequel, and that film's poor returns ended the Kate Lloyd sequel. The 1982 ending, I think, keeps The Thing 2 talk alive: Dread Central says Carpenter sees MacReady and Childs as both alive, and "we'll see" is still the most reliable release date. For Body Snatchers sequels, Wikipedia gives no reason Solo's never came. My reading is that every ending, the novel's above all, is closed or bleak, and the 1993 film's tiny US run gave nobody a reason to ask. Remakes were easier to sell.